by Jonny Sicko » Fri Sep 02, 2011 11:09 am
I don't think even a trilogy (or more) for The Stand would work. There are so many characters, so many concepts going on this book...and typically making a series of movies takes years, that important details may be overlooked. I wasn't terribly impressed with Yate's work on the Harry Potter movies. I don't believe he even read the books prior to filming. I think the best treatment for a 1200+ page book is a Showtime/Starz/HBO mini-series over the course of several seasons. I mean the whole entire purpose of the book wasn't the horror, it wasn't the action, wasn't even really the characters themselves...those are all incidental. The purpose was, if the world became like this and all of the tools were just left around waiting to be picked up and used again...would we rebuild the world the same way? At least that's what I gathered from it. If that point is missed, then several movies worth of content are completely pointless. From Yate's work on Harry Potter, it seems entire plot lines don't matter. He likes to concentrate on the bullshit and extend it rather than shine a light on what's important.